Friday, 17 October 2025

The cake that never fails?

 

Faced with a recipe called ‘Cacen BythYn Methu’ (The cake that never fails), I was intrigued to find out if this was the philosopher’s stone of baking. Had I hit the jackpot for the ultimate cake?

Too much sugar?

I took one look at the amount of sugar in this recipe and decided to not to add any at all. I’m going along in Grandma Abson’s tradition of following your instincts when it comes to baking. For me, the amount of dried fruit alongside the pineapple would seem to make it sweet enough. I used the pineapple juice to make the mixture a little softer. But, if you feel the need for a sugar kick, the original recipe says 60z (175g) soft brown sugar. Add it to the fruit mixture when you are melting the butter in the pan. Here’s my version:

Cacen BythYn Methu (heb siwgr)

4 0zs (110g) glazed cherries

4 ozs (110g) butter

2 eggs

1 small can (220g) pineapple (crushed)

12 ozs (350g) mixed dried fruit

8 ozs (220g) self-raising flour (sifted)

1.      Preheat the oven to 170C, 325 F or Gas Mark 3).

2.     Chop the cherries (I washed and dried them first) and put them in a large pan with the pineapple (chopped or crushed into smaller pieces), butter and dried fruit.

3.     Heat to melt the butter but DO NOT BOIL.

4.    Leave this mixture to cool.

5.     Beat in the sifted flour and eggs.

6.    Add enough pineapple juice to make the mixture less stiff.

7.     Put in a lined baking tin (I used a 20 cms x 30 cms tin). Bake in the oven for one hour until firm. Remove and place the tin on a rack to cool before removing the cake from the tin.

Meryl’s other tips

·        I’ve tried this recipe adding other types of dried fruit such as cranberries and apricots in the mix and a chopped apple. They all worked well. It’s a very versatile recipe.

·        Use a thin cake tester to stick in the cake and check if the cake is baked. I checked after 55 minutes. There should be no trace of the mixture when the cake tester is taken out, but if traces of the mixture remain, then it needs a little more baking time.

A recipe for success

I ‘ve never made a fruit cake with pineapple before but it turned out very well. I wrapped it up and took it on a walk with my Railway walking group friends when we tackled the renamed Suffragette line (formerly Overground) in north London. It proved a real treat – perfect for a picnic too!

   Bench dedicated to the last Suffragette 
Annie Clara Huggett from Barking

This is a shorter version of a piece I've written for Yorkshire Bylines about this intriguing recipe.